+27 71 448 3496
leon@whyafrica.co.za

Dispute resolution under the African Continental Free Trade Agreement

Share Article
The African Union at its organs like the Pan African Parliament are finalising all the finer details of the African Continental Free Trade Agreement. Image credit: Leon Louw for WhyAfrica.

Dispute resolution under the African Continental Free Trade Agreement

The recently adopted African Continental Free Trade Agreement (AfCFTA) Protocol on Investment will be followed by an Annex which will tackle the contentious issue of regulating trade and investment disputes without impinging on national sovereignty.

By Chandni Gopal, Sarah McKenzie and Yael Shafrir.

On 19 February 2023, the African Union Heads of State agreed to adopt a Protocol on Investment (Protocol) to the AfCFTA.

The Protocol aims not only to encourage intra-Africa investment flows and opportunities but also to protect the sustainable development of member states and to incorporate Environmental, Social and Governance (ESG) principles in a way that is relevant to Africa.

While the adopted Protocol is not publicly available, the final draft version provides insight into its objectives and how member states will seek to achieve them.

Currently, foreign investment on the continent is regulated by a complex web of regional, bilateral, and national investment treaties. The Protocol seeks to replace bilateral investment treaties through the renegotiation of a regional investment treaty.

Sound legal framework (Dispute resolution under the African Continental Free Trade Agreement)

One of the Protocol’s important stated objectives is to provide a sound legal framework for the prevention, management, and settlement of investment disputes. This issue has been rather contentious.

While the latest draft Protocol includes provisions related to state-state dispute settlement (Article 44) and dispute prevention and grievance management (Article 45), it does not currently contain concrete provisions on dispute resolution when these measures have failed.

Article 46, which deals with dispute resolution, indicates that rules and procedures governing dispute resolution will be negotiated and set out in an Annex which will be finalised and adopted within 12 months of the date that the Protocol is adopted.

It is not surprising that the Annex remains the subject of scrutiny and protracted negotiation between AfCFTA member states.

The resolution of trade disputes between investors and states is a complex and thorny issue on the continent. Historically, investment treaties have included Investor-State Dispute Settlement or “ISDS” provisions.

ISDS provisions provide that an investor from one country (the “home state”) who has invested in another country (the “host state”) can bring a claim directly against the host state in an arbitral forum, rather than in the domestic courts of the host state.

Without ISDS, investors wanting to enforce their rights would have to seek the intervention of their home government, if the actions of a host state caused them harm or loss of profit or rely on actions in the local courts of the host state. ISDS provisions were a breakthrough, giving investors a direct right of recourse and protection. They were widely assumed to boost foreign direct investment.

Steering investment away from ISDS (Dispute resolution under the African Continental Free Trade Agreement)

However, because ISDS provisions give investors an almost unfettered power to institute proceedings directly against sovereign states, they have been criticised for limiting governments’ ability to regulate as they see fit.

These regulations would relate to, for example, furthering public policy goals, protecting the environment or, in South Africa’s case, advancing black economic empowerment.

For this reason, both South Africa and Tanzania have passed laws steering investment disputes away from ISDS. Although the Annex on dispute resolution is still in draft form, it is anticipated, based on an earlier draft of the Protocol that included a first version of the Annex, that it will include the possibility of international arbitration.

A statement by the Task Force responsible for finalising the Annex suggests that the relevant “dispute resolution mechanisms … could include, amongst others, utilising the Dispute Settlement Body established under the AfCFTA Protocol on Dispute Settlement or arbitration or domestic or regional courts”.

Regulating their own affairs (Dispute resolution under the African Continental Free Trade Agreement)

If some version of arbitration is included in the Annex, it is encouraging that the latest available version of the Protocol seeks to balance investor protection with the right of member states to regulate their own affairs, especially sustainable development.

For example, Article 13 provides that measures taken by member states that are “designed and applied to protect or enhance legitimate public policy objectives such as, but not limited to, public morals, public health, prevention of diseases and pests in animals or plants, climate action, essential security interests, safety and the protection of environment” should not be construed as a breach of the protections afforded to foreign investors.

This approach is in keeping with AfCFTA’s affirmation of the importance of ESG principles and objectives in a way that is relevant to Africa. It is also in line with a recommendation by the UNCITRAL working group on ISDS reform that investors’ access to ISDS ought to be circumscribed in sensitive policy areas.

Promoting sustainable development (Dispute resolution under the African Continental Free Trade Agreement)

In addition, there is an entire chapter of the Protocol dedicated to Sustainable Development-Related Issues, which reaffirms the right of member states to regulate and adopt measures aimed at promoting sustainable development.

Article 24 specifically provides that measures taken by member states to comply with international obligations under relevant treaties will not constitute a breach of the Protocol. This is especially important in the context of climate commitments such as the Paris Agreement and the need to phase out fossil fuels over time, a move that could otherwise breach investment protections.

Linked to this, there has been a suggestion (based on what was included in an earlier draft of the Protocol) that the Annex is likely to include a mechanism that allows member states to file counterclaims.

This would allow host governments to invoke relevant international treaties such as those relating to human rights, ESG imperatives and sustainable development in defending claims and would allow member states to counterclaim for breaches of investor obligations set out in the Protocol.

The AfCFTA creates the largest free trade area in the world, in terms of geographical size and population, and it has the potential to radically transform trade and investment in Africa.

As the Annex is negotiated, member states will need to engage with difficult question about whether or not to include ISDS, and how to ensure adequate investor protection more broadly.

While the stakes are high, there is an opportunity for Africa to forge a new approach in this highly contested area.

Chandni Gopal is a Partner at Webber Wentzel, Sarah McKenzie is a Partner at Webber Wentzel and Yael Shafrir is a Consultant at Webber Wentzel.

Dispute resolution under the African Continental Free Trade Agreement

WhyAfrica provides on the ground information and business intelligence about the sustainable utilisation and extraction of natural resources in Africa, and can assist your company through:  

  1. Membership:
  • WhyAfrica’s membership offers great business insights to you, your company, and clients.
  • Amongst many other benefits, we will publish editorial content about you or your company on the WhyAfrica online platform and on all WhyAfrica’s social media pages – the annual fee is R5,500 and you can find out more or subscribe here: https://www.whyafrica.co.za/product/membership/ 
  1. Sponsorship:
  • WhyAfrica’s annual 45-day African Road Trip takes place in July and August. We will visit more than 30 project sites and this year we plan to visit Angola, Zambia and Malawi. Sponsoring the Road Trip, or to be a WhyAfrica member, gives you unparalleled insight into the business environment of the countries that we travel to and the project sites we visit.
  • To be a member or sponsor allows you access to invaluable, on the ground, business intelligence and a great marketing opportunity for all companies doing business in Africa.
  • The main aim of our Road Trips is to promote Africa as an investment destination and to showcase Africa’s greatest companies, and projects to our large global audience, which includes a list of potential investors, venture capitalists and serial entrepreneurs.
  • To view the photos of last year’s Southern Africa Road Trip click on the gallery link or follow our Instagram account at why.africa https://www.whyafrica.co.za/road-trips/whyafrica-road-trips/. 
  1. Advertising:
  • We publish daily online articles on our WhyAfrica platform and post them on social media every day. Our combined online reach is more than 45,000. In-article banner ads are highly successful advertising tools as is advertising space on our website.
  • In addition to our bi-weekly newsletters, we publish two printed- and two interactive digital magazines per year. The printed magazines are distributed at major events and conferences throughout the year, and also on our WhyAfrica Road trips.
  • Digital magazines are e-mailed to all our subscribers and shared on our social media platforms. A copy of the latest edition is automatically attached to all our outgoing e-mails.
  • WhyAfrica magazines provide great marketing opportunities. There are also in-article and on-line advertising opportunities at exceptional rates. Contact me for more information on leon@whyafrica.co.za or give me a call.
  • To subscribe to WhyAfrica’s free newsletters and magazines click on the link and register: https://www.whyafrica.co.za/subscribe/  
  1. 4. Partnerships
  • Maximise your African exposure and link with our large business network through becoming one of only 10 WhyAfrica partners. We have only five prime partnership positions left for 2023, so contact me at leon@whyafrica.co.za before the end of March to get the best deal. 

Dispute resolution under the African Continental Free Trade Agreement

 

Share Article

Sectors

AgricultureEnvironmental Management & Climate ChangeEnergyESGInfrastructureMiningPolitical EconomyTourism and ConservationWater Management