+27 71 448 3496
leon@whyafrica.co.za

Can a mining company get ‘SLAPP-ed’?

Share Article
Muhammed Khan, Director at NSDV. Image credit: NSDV

Can a mining company get ‘SLAPP-ed’?

 Can a mining company get ‘SLAPP-ed’? The short answer is… probably not. By Muhammed Khan, Director at NSDV.

By Muhammed Khan

When we think about ‘SLAPP’ or Strategic Litigation Against Public Participation, we think about big companies using their considerable resources to institute litigious proceedings, seeking exorbitant amounts of damages from persons who, for example, criticised their mining operations.

These big companies’ goal is not to recover the damages but rather to intimidate and silence such persons which could include civil society, the public, and media.

‘SLAPP’ was a novel defence raised by defendants who were being sued by two related mining companies (and certain directors thereof) for defamation in the matter of Mineral Sands Resources (Pty) Ltd v Reddell.

The court described SLAPP in great detail and stated “Essentially its [SLAPP] aim is to silence those challenging powerful corporates on issues of public concern. In essence the main purpose of the suit is to punish or retaliate against citizens who have spoken out against the plaintiffs… The signature elements of SLAPP cases is the use of the legal system, usually disguised as an ordinary civil claim, designed to discourage others from speaking on issues of public importance and exploiting the inequalities of finances and human resources available to large corporations compared to the targets…”.

The court held that the defamation suit was not genuine and in good faith but merely a pretext with the purpose to silence opponents and critics. The court further recognised that the SLAPP suit defence constituted a valid defence in South African law against the defamation suit.

Considering the description of SLAPP, it is highly unlikely that a mining company could fall victim to it. However, this does not mean that abuses of legal process cannot be used against mining companies.

Can a mining company get ‘SLAPP-ed’?

Mining in South Africa is highly regulated and requires numerous licences, authorisations, and other similar regulatory approvals to lawfully undertake. To mine in South Africa, a company needs at a minimum, the following:

  1. A mining right issued in terms of the Mineral and Petroleum Resources Development Act, 2002 (“MPRDA”);
  2. An environmental authorisation issued in terms of the National Environmental Management Act, 1998 (“NEMA”); and
  3. A water use licence issued in terms of the National Water Act, 1998 (“NWA”).

The MPRDA, NEMA and the NWA each make provision for appeals against decisions taken by the relevant regulator to issue licences under the relevant Act. For example, the issuing of a mining right can be appealed under section 96 of the MPRDA, the issuing of an environmental authorisation (“EA”) can be appealed under section 43 of NEMA, and the issuing of a water use licence (“WUL”) can be appealed under section 148 of the NWA.

The appeal in terms of section 96 of the MPRDA does not automatically suspend the issuing of the mining right and the holder (despite the lodgment of the appeal) could theoretically still mine under the mining right. However, a company does not only require a mining right to mine. It would still likely require an EA and WUL. Considering this, an appeal lodged against the issuing of an EA or a WUL has the effect of immediately/automatically suspending the relevant EA or WUL.

See where this is going…

Once an appeal against the issuing of an EA or WUL has been lodged, the holder would no longer be able to undertake the listed activities or water uses authrorised thereunder (because of the immediate/automatic suspension) and will not be able to commence mining.

For a major mining company, the hold placed on one mine or operation may not have a devastating impact. However, for a junior miner with a single mining operation, such a stoppage could have potentially devastating and dire consequences, not only for the junior miner but for its employees and the surrounding community which would otherwise benefit from the mining (through the fulfilment of social and labour obligations).

Both NEMA and the NWA provide that the respective Minister (responsible for the administration of the Act) may direct that the relevant authorisation or licence is not suspended pending the determination of the relevant lodged appeal. However, there is no prescribed method or time frame to obtain the relevant Minister’s upliftment.

To further exacerbate matters, whilst both the MPRDA and NEMA provide for time periods for the determination of their respective appeals, the time periods are rarely adhered to by certain of the regulators and the determination of the appeal usually takes a significant amount of time. Furthermore, the NWA has no time periods for the determination of an appeal in terms of section 148 of the NWA.

In the lodging of appeals, certain interested groups such as civil society but even competing mining companies could potentially seek to halt mining operations by lodging frivolous appeals. This would likely not be a SLAPP but more of a SLAM (Strategic Litigation Against Mining).

So, what can be done?

Should mining companies be lobbying lawmakers for legislative reform? In typical legislative proceedings before a court, if a party loses a matter, they are generally ordered to pay the legal costs of the other litigating party (usually on a predetermined scale). A similar reform could be introduced to dissuade frivolous appeals from being lodged, particularly where they have the effect of automatically suspending the relevant licence or authorisation. Additionally, the applicable legislative provisions could better define the way in which an automatic suspension is uplifted following the lodging of an appeal.

Ironically, this type of legislative reform to include the potential of having an adverse cost order could similarly be used by companies to intimidate or prevent the lodgement of appeals (which is the purpose of a SLAPP).

Whether it’s a SLAPP or a SLAM, legislative measures should be introduced to dissuade the lodging of frivolous appeals. However, should a frivolous appeal still be lodged, such appeal should be vehemently opposed, not only because it may have very serious ramifications for a mining company, but also to curb any such similar conduct in the future.

Muhammed Khan is a Director at NSDV.

Can a mining company get ‘SLAPP-ed’?

WhyAfrica reports about, and publishes newsletters, magazines and research reports about natural resources and the primary sectors of African economies, and the infrastructure, equipment and engineering methods needed to extract and utilise these resources in an efficient, responsible, sustainable, ethic and environmentally friendly way, so that it will benefit the people of Africa.

Furthermore, WhyAfrica promotes Africa as an investment and travel destination, analyses the continent’s business environment and investment opportunities, and reports on how the political economy of African countries affects its development.         

WhyAfrica provides you with business intelligence that matters. Africa is our business, and we want it to be yours too. To subscribe to WhyAfrica’s free newsletter or digital magazine, and for more news on Africa, visit the website at www.whyafrica.co.za or send a direct message. WhyAfrica launched its first ever digital magazine in November 2021.

The company will undertake its annual road trip through South Africa, Zimbabwe, Zambia, the DRC, Malawi, Tanzania and Kenya in 2023. If you are interested in sponsorship or advertising opportunities, please contact me at leon@whyafrica.co.za. We have a wide range of different packages and combo deals to give your company the greatest exposure to a rapidly growing, African readership.  

The 2022 Southern Africa Road trip issue of WhyAfrica’s magazine is now available in print. The magazine was distributed in South Africa, Namibia, Zambia, Zimbabwe, and Botswana during WhyAfrica’s 2022 Southern Africa Overland Road Trip, the company’s new and innovative platform. WhyAfrica has expanded its product range and now offers its readers, followers, advertisers, subscribers and partners the following:

  • Daily 24/7 online articles on WhyAfrica’s website (FREE)
  • Daily updates on WhyAfrica’s social media platforms (FREE)
  • Newsletters delivered to a handpicked audience every two weeks (FREE)
  • Two printed magazine per year distributed at large events and during our road trips across Africa featuring original, in-depth articles (FREE) with great, on-site photographs by the WhyAfrica team (FOR SALE UPON REQUEST)
  • Four digital magazines per year (FREE)
  • Live updates, video clips, articles, and podcasts during and after WhyAfrica’s annual road trips (Southern Africa in 2022, East Africa in 2023 and West Africa in 2024) (FREE)
  • Sponsorship and advertising opportunities for the annual WhyAfrica Overland Road Trips (PAID FOR)
  • A library where companies doing business in Africa can display scientific or research papers (PAID FOR)
  • A product section where companies doing business in Africa can display new offerings or services (PAID FOR)
  • Media partnerships with, and a presence at, most of the major conferences and exhibitions in the African mining, energy, agriculture, infrastructure, water management, ESG, environmental management, tourism, development, and conservation sectors (FREE)
  • WhyAfrica connects potential investors with new ventures in Africa and suppliers and service providers with existing companies in Africa (PAID FOR)
  • WhyAfrica assists companies in generating content focused on the wider African business community (PAID FOR)
  • Partnerships with companies doing business in Africa (PAID FOR)
  • Partnerships with companies thinking about expanding into Africa (PAID FOR)
  • In 2023 subscribers will have access to our in-depth articles about the African political economy, research, and country reports about the countries we visit on our road trips, and trends in the sectors that we cover (PAID FOR)
  • A WhyAfrica book is in the pipeline and if all goes according to plan, should be published towards the end of 2023 (PAID FOR)
  • The WhyAfrica consultancy arm assists and advises companies doing business in Africa through utilising our extensive global business network (PAID FOR)

Become part of the WhyAfrica community. Tell us your story. Expand your footprint across Africa and partner with us to make the most of your African experience. 

Can a mining company get ‘SLAPP-ed’?

Share Article

Sectors

AgricultureEnvironmental Management & Climate ChangeEnergyESGInfrastructureMiningPolitical EconomyTourism and ConservationWater Management